Drug makers defend empty space in pill bottles

2022-05-25 09:54:16 By : Mr. Michael Xu

Taking tips, chasing leads, and solving problems

By Gitte Laasby of the Journal Sentinel

You've probably had the experience of opening an expensive bottle of pills or nutrition supplements just to discover that the container was only a quarter or half full.

If you felt cheated, bitter or puzzled, you're not the only one. Many consumers ask themselves the same question: Is there a valid reason that these bottles contain so much empty space? Or are manufacturers just trying to give consumers the impression that there's more in the bottle so we don't get deterred from buying the pills because they cost so much for such a small amount?

Well, several consumers complained about "slack fill" as it's called (the difference between actual capacity of the container and the volume of the product) so Consumer Reports investigated. Here are some of the explanations that the publication received along with a couple others I found:

The federal Fair Packaging and Labeling Act is supposed to prevent consumers from excessive slack fill so we don't get the illusion of more product if the extra space isn't necessary. Extra space is allowed if the package also serves as a dispenser or tray or to discourage theft (it's easier to steal small packages), for instance.

The federal government rarely sues manufacturers for excessive slack fill. In fact, one of the most recent cases was in 2008. It involved Mucinex packages, which contained 90% cardboard, cotton and air and only 10% pills.

One expert pointed out that manufacturers have to be careful not to make consumers so angry or dissatisfied that they lose their business.

Wisconsin residents can file a complaint about slack fill with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration by calling (612) 758-7221 or emailing oramincomplaints@fda.hhs.gov.

For more consumer stories, follow Gitte Laasby @GitteLaasbyMJS or get news straight to your Facebook page by liking her page.

Gitte Laasby is the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's Public Investigator. She investigates government issues and consumer affairs.

Do you have an issue with government or a local business or a story idea for Public Investigator? Contact us:

Recent recalls and product safety news from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.

Recalls and safety alerts from the Food and Drug Administration and Dept. of Agriculture.

All Politics Blog Ron Johnson touts ground game for fall campaign

Proof and Hearsay Tiny school district feels big financial pain from Woznicki records requests

No Quarter Blog Radio host: Baldwin would have acted in Tomah VA scandal "if dead vets had been gay"

School Zone Interest rates dropping July 1 for new federal student loans

Uncommon Causey Eric Von suffered a heart attack

Pulse MCW researcher is lead author of genetic study on most common type of hearing loss

The Wisconsin Voter No crossover appeal for Trump and Clinton in Wisconsin

The Smart Set Donald Trump: Where were the signs?

Across the Board Good news for the Great Lakes

Ideas They don't call it the 'bully pulpit' for nothing

A Word With You BuzzFeed's expose of "The New American Slavery"